17 November 2026 · 7 minute read
Beat Detective vs Elastic Audio: when to use which
One cuts, one stretches. Both fix timing. The choice comes down to how many tracks are involved, whether the tempo moves, and what you are willing to hear afterwards.
Pro Tools has two ways to move a performance in time. Beat Detective finds the hits in a selection and cuts the audio into clips at those hits, so you can slide the clips onto the grid or onto a groove. Elastic Audio analyzes the audio for events and lets you warp the time between them, stretching and squeezing without cutting. They solve the same problem with opposite tools, and most timing jobs are clearly one or the other once you know what each one costs.
What Beat Detective does
Event > Beat Detective (Cmd+8 on the numeric keypad). You capture a selection and tell it the bar range, then pick a mode:
- Bar|Beat Marker Generation builds a tempo map from a performance, so the grid follows the drummer instead of the other way round.
- Groove Template Extraction saves the timing and dynamics of a performance as a template you can quantize other things to.
- Clip Separation cuts the selection at every detected transient above the sensitivity you set, at the resolution you choose (bars, beats, sub-beats).
- Clip Conform moves those clips to the grid or a groove, with a strength percentage so you can tighten without flattening.
- Edit Smoothing fills the gaps the conform opened, trims the overlaps and adds crossfades.
The important thing is that the audio inside each clip is untouched. No stretching, no artifacts, no change to the attack of a snare. What changes is where each clip sits.
What Elastic Audio does
Enable it from the Elastic Audio plug-in selector on the track (under the voice selector in the Edit window). Pick an algorithm: Polyphonic for most things, Rhythmic for drums and percussion, Monophonic for a single voice or bass, Varispeed when pitch should follow time, X-Form for the best quality when rendering. Pro Tools analyzes the track for events, and in Warp view you drag warp markers to move time, or use Event > Event Operations > Quantize to conform the detected events to the grid. Tick-based Elastic tracks follow tempo changes on their own.
The important thing here is the opposite: nothing is cut, so nothing opens up and nothing needs smoothing, but every bit of audio between two warp markers has been stretched or squeezed, and the algorithm has an opinion about how that should sound.
Use Beat Detective when
It is a multitrack drum kit. This is the big one. Select all the drum tracks together and Beat Detective cuts them at the same points, so every mic moves by the same amount and the phase relationships between kick, snare, overheads and room stay intact. Elastic Audio warps each track on its own analysis, and even small differences between tracks smear the kit. For a drum kit with more than two or three mics, cut.
You want the attack untouched. Stretching a snare hit by even a few percent softens its transient. Cutting does not.
You need a groove, not a grid. Groove Template Extraction from a great take, applied to a stiff one, is still the most musical way to tighten a rhythm section in Pro Tools.
You want the grid to follow the band. Bar|Beat Marker Generation gives you a tempo map from the drummer, so everything recorded after follows a human tempo.
Use Elastic Audio when
It is one track. A bass that drags behind a tightened kit, a vocal phrase that lands late, a guitar strum that rushes. Enable Elastic Audio, find the event, move it in Warp view. No cuts, no fades, done.
The tempo moves. If the song has a tempo map with ramps, a tick-based Elastic track follows it. Beat Detective clips do not follow later tempo changes; they sit where you put them.
You need a sustained note to fit. A held vocal or a pad that needs to end on the downbeat cannot be cut to fit; it has to be stretched. Monophonic or Polyphonic, real time while you decide, Rendered when you commit.
It is a loop or a sample at the wrong tempo. Drop it on a tick-based Elastic track and it conforms to the session tempo as it lands.
You are previewing. Elastic Audio is reversible by turning it off. Beat Detective is reversible by Undo, which is less comfortable two hours later.
What each one costs afterwards
Beat Detective leaves gaps and overlaps. Edit Smoothing handles most of them, but you will listen through for clicks and for fill clips that grabbed the wrong room tone. Zoom in at the cuts on the overheads; that is where the trouble hides. Consolidate the tracks when you are happy so the next person does not inherit four hundred clips.
Elastic Audio leaves artifacts. Rhythmic on anything with sustain flutters; Polyphonic on a sharp transient smears it. Listen to the stretched regions in isolation. When the timing is right, Commit or render the track (right-click > Commit, or switch the track to Rendered) so the plug-in stops working in real time and the result is fixed as audio.
Both, in order
On a full band the usual sequence is: Beat Detective on the drums, consolidated; then Elastic Audio on the bass, conformed to the new drums; then anything else by ear with Elastic in Warp view. Cut the many-track things, stretch the single-track things. If you find yourself cutting a lead vocal into forty clips, stop and switch tools. If you find yourself warping eight drum mics one at a time, same.
A short decision list
- More than two tracks that have to stay phase-coherent: Beat Detective.
- One track, a few notes to move: Elastic Audio.
- Tempo changes during the song: Elastic Audio, tick-based.
- A groove to copy from one take to another: Beat Detective.
- Something that has to be longer or shorter, not just earlier or later: Elastic Audio.
- Transients that must not soften: Beat Detective.
How Pete does this
Session Pilot is a Mac app. You talk, and Punch In Pete works Pro Tools. Timing is editorial, so this is a place to be clear about what he does and does not do. He does the setup and the housekeeping around both tools; the listening and the decisions are yours.
Select the drum tracks from verse 1 to the end of chorus 1 and open Beat Detective.
Turn on Elastic Audio on the bass, Monophonic, and show Warp view.
Consolidate the drum tracks and put the Beat Detective edits in a new playlist first.
Selections, playlists, opening the windows, enabling Elastic Audio on a track, consolidating, committing: those are his. He does not pick the sensitivity, move a warp marker or decide which take has the better groove, and he will not pretend to. He gets you to the point where the only thing left to do is the part that needs ears, and he reads back what he did so you know the selection is the one you asked for.
Not just another bounce or session prep app. Pete is the best assistant you'll ever have.
Session Pilot launches 16 December 2026 for Mac. Everyone on the wait list gets launch pricing locked and a 14-day free trial.
Join the wait listSession Pilot is not affiliated with or endorsed by Avid Technology, Inc. Pro Tools is a trademark of Avid Technology, Inc. Menu paths refer to Pro Tools 2026.11; older versions may differ.